Thursday, March 14, 2013

India and China : A Comparison

India and China : A Comparison

China is a unitary polity and India is Federal polity.

China began with a closed economy with no free trade and commerce and media until Mao Zedong regime -1978. Thereafter it adopted a more liberal approach, allowed private sector to flourish. It’s a perfect example of state capitalism wherein government holds control over major heavy and energy industries but allowed private sector(around 30 billion private business) to expand. It has imposed heavy restriction on press, Internet, reproduction, freedom of religion and freedom of assembly. Since state plays a dominant role it can align maximum resources to achieve a goal.

Whereas India on other hand, is a federal republic with independent media, Judiciary and provides more freedom to people. It started with closed economy, but allowed privatization, liberalization and globalization in 1991 and the period thereafter is marked with big reforms and high economic growth. It’s a largest democracy with thousands of castes, tribes following different religions.

In 1952, India’s per-capita income is $60 whereas China was $50. But the story is reversed now. China has around 200+ billionaires and India has only 70+  billionaires. China is 2nd largest by nominal as well as PPP GDP wheras India is 3rd largest by nominal and 10th largest by PPP GDP. China has 2nd largest defence budget. It invest more in education, health and imparting skills.  China is expected to surpass USA by 2018 with GDP growth rate -9.2% wheras India economy is expected to grow at 6-6.5%. China is ranked 31st and India 50th in world competitive ranking. China is Current account surplus country, no longer dependent on FDI, FII, with huge foreign exchange reserves($3.31 Tn). India is current account deicit and needs FDI, FII and ECB to finance it.

But despite having high growth rate, China’s will be forced to adopt more democratic setup, give more freedom to people otherwise it may lead to civil unrest. India,on the other hand needs to make sure that it provides skills and education, bring in inclusive growth so that it can harness the rich demographic dividend. India further has an advantage that average age of its population is 28 years whereas China’s 38 years.
India don’t have to chase China in economic growth but rather needs to work on education, skills, health. An elephant doesn't need wings to surpass dragon in all round growth.